10Ten-Year LensDuan Yongping's ideas, re-told EN中
← All texts

EP 22 · Nov 16, 2026 · 5:34

You Are Asking the Wrong Person

5:34

A reader wanted the complete record of everything he had written on the forum, from the earliest posts. He said there is no record.

Text

The question

This is Ten Year Lens — twenty years of Duan Yongping's public answers, translated, plus our reading of it. He is one of Asia's most successful investors.

A reader asked where the older half of his public writing had gone, and said that reading it in full was the thing he most wanted to do.

Quote

I do not collect the things I have said myself — you are asking the wrong person.

The one sentence above is a direct quotation. Everything else on this page is our own summary and reading of it.

Our reading

The reader had been following him for about a year and wanted to go back to the beginning — to read the whole body of what he had written on that forum, in order, from the earliest posts. He could only find material going back a couple of years, and asked where the rest could be found.

The strange part is the asymmetry. Here is a man who has answered questions in public for over a decade, thousands of them, on balance sheets and on how to live, and he owns no copy. He is not being coy about the volume. He simply never treated his own words as an asset that needed storing. The reader assumed the archive was the valuable object and that the author would be its custodian. He does not seem to think there is an archive at all — only a habit of answering, which happened to leave marks.

Think about what a complete record would be for. The reader's reason is the good one: read it all in order, and absorb the way the man thinks. That plan has a hidden assumption — that the thinking is stored in the sentences. It is not. The sentences are the residue. What produced them was a way of putting questions to a business, and that part was never written down anywhere, which is exactly why copying conclusions out of the archive tends to fail in the hands of the person who copied them.

There is a second reason he might not want one, and it is less flattering. A curated record turns answers into positions. Once the positions are collected and indexed, consistency becomes a constraint: the next answer has to survive comparison with the last one. Being able to change your mind in public is a luxury, and it is far cheaper when nobody has assembled the file. Uncollected words can be revised. Collected words have to be defended.

There is also a plain mechanical reason, which has nothing to do with modesty. Answers age. A reply about a company from a decade ago is mostly archaeology — the numbers have moved, the product has changed, the situation that made the question urgent is over. What survives is the shape of the reasoning, and a shape does not need every sentence to become visible. It needs a reader willing to rebuild it from a handful of examples, which is slower, worse, and the only version that stays.

Then comes the exception, which is the part people skip. He does keep one record, and he keeps it involuntarily: the quarterly list of what his firm owns, with sizes attached. That document is public, it cannot be edited for style, and it is the only place where his judgement is stated in numbers rather than in prose. The pairing is odd — the words unarchived, the holdings filed — and it says something about which of the two he considers the evidence.

For anyone on the receiving end of all this, the practical instruction runs the other way. Do not build a folder of answers. Build the short record you cannot fake: what you own, why you own it, what would make you sell. Three columns, honestly filled, will teach you more than a decade of somebody else's sentences, because it is the only text in the room that is about your own reasoning rather than his.

The letter itself deserves a second look, because most of it is not a question. It is a year of gratitude, a list of habits, an account of what the reading did for him. He replies to the request and lets every word of that pass. Praise is not information, and answering it costs exactly the attention that answering something useful would cost. What he is protecting is not modesty; it is the small remaining budget for the things he can actually settle.

A question back

And the archive the reader wanted does exist. Strangers assembled it, screenshot by screenshot, because they found it worth keeping. It was built by the people being helped rather than by the person doing the helping, which is probably the honest way for a body of advice to survive. What is missing from it is the part that mattered, and no amount of copying will put that back — which is why the reply is not a refusal to help. It is a correction about where the help lives.

Disclaimer: an independent re-organisation and re-statement. Not official, and not affiliated with, licensed by or endorsed by any person or institution. Nothing here is investment advice — decide for yourself.