Text
The question
This is Ten Year Lens — twenty years of Duan Yongping's public answers, translated, plus our reading of it. He is one of Asia's most successful investors.
A reader asked, in as many words, to be talked out of it. He had put everything into one liquor stock, watched it fall, run out of cash, and was now considering borrowing to buy more. He wanted someone to say no.
Quote
We do not know how crazy the market can get, and we do not know how bad things can become. Not using margin is a basic requirement of investing. We have always talked about ten or twenty years, but margin can put you in trouble before then. There is no need for it.
The one sentence above is a direct quotation. Everything else on this page is our own summary and reading of it.
Our reading
Of all the rules he has repeated over twenty years, this is the one he calls basic. The word is his. Not advanced, not sophisticated, not something for professionals with strong stomachs. A basic requirement — as in a floor you are either above or below, with no third option.
The reason is not moral, and it is not really about volatility. Borrowed money does not change what you own. It changes who decides when you sell. The shares sit in an account controlled by the broker, and when the collateral falls far enough, the decision to sell is no longer yours. It is a call, and it arrives at the worst hour of the worst week.
That is the mechanical half. Here is the half he puts in one sentence: we have always talked about ten or twenty years, and margin can put you in trouble before that. Two clocks, running at different speeds. The business needs a decade to prove the judgement right. The loan needs servicing next month. When two clocks disagree, the faster one wins — and it wins by ending the position.
Note what that means. Being right about the business does not save you. You can be completely correct about what a company will earn in ten years, and still be forced out in year two at a price that turns a temporary decline into a permanent loss. The business recovers. The account does not.
He tells a story that puts a face on it. Someone he knows started with twenty thousand dollars, used large amounts of margin for about twenty years, and built it into something in the neighbourhood of two billion. The man was never happy. He was always tense. In one financial crisis a single morning nearly erased him, and he sold everything to keep a small seed of it.
That is the part people skip when they retell it as a success. Twenty years of being right, and one morning that came within hours of taking all of it. On paper the expected value of that life may look fine. Nobody lives on paper.
The same logic applies to a business, which is where most people stop listening. He has said debt is a dangerous thing, roughly the same as margin — and that inside a company it can be worse, because the assets are hard to sell, and when the trouble arrives you cannot run. His comment on growing more slowly was: it is much healthier.
Why do intelligent people do it anyway? Because leverage works most of the time. Most months the borrowed money makes more money, and every one of those months teaches the same lesson: this is fine. The feedback is asymmetric — years of confirmation, then one event that erases the years. That is the shape of every account that gets wiped out, and it has nothing to do with being stupid.
He has also pointed at a tell, in one short exchange. Someone described their results as falling harder than the index when it falls, and rising harder when it rises — and offered it as a virtue. His reply was a single question: that only happens if you are using margin, so how have the last few years felt?
One honest wrinkle, because another of his tools deserves it. Selling puts also creates an obligation — a commitment to buy at a price, at a moment you do not choose. The difference is that a cash-secured put is an obligation you can meet with money you already have. Margin is an obligation you meet with money you hope to have. The line between them is not the instrument. It is whose money is at stake, and whether the calendar can force your hand.
A question back
So the question to take away is not how much you could borrow. It is: at what price would I be forced to sell? Write that number down, then compare it with today's. If the two are close, you are not investing with borrowed money. You are investing with a deadline — and a deadline is the one thing no business negotiated with.