Text
The question
This is Ten Year Lens — twenty years of Duan Yongping's public answers, translated, plus our reading of it. He is one of Asia's most successful investors.
A reader asked what he thought about the leverage, after describing a plan that was otherwise about holding and waiting.
Quote
If you want a more exciting life, use a bit more leverage. What you can gain is very limited, but if you do gain it, you will benefit for the rest of your life. That benefit is usually called a lesson.
The one sentence above is a direct quotation. Everything else on this page is our own summary and reading of it.
Our reading
A reader described an ordinary situation. He has a job. He invests on the side, mostly in one liquor company plus some American shares, and his plan is simply to hold. What he wants is for the dividends to cover his living costs one day. Then, in the last line, he mentions that he has added some leverage.
Start with how ordinary the setup is, because the answer is not aimed at a reckless person. A job, a holding, a hope that the dividends will eventually cover the groceries. That is a modest plan, and most of it is sound. Then one clause at the end changes the arithmetic of the whole thing, and the entire reply is aimed at that clause.
Notice the shape of the reply, because the shape is the argument. He does not say leverage is wrong. He grants the wish first — you want more excitement — and then he puts a price on it. The price is not a percentage and it is not a probability. It is a lesson, which in this usage means a loss you will remember for the rest of your life. He has priced it in the only currency that never inflates. The joke is not decoration; it is the shortest version of an argument he makes at length elsewhere.
The phrase about limited upside is worth unpacking, because it sounds like an opinion and it is arithmetic. Leverage does not change what the business earns. It changes how much of the swing you get to keep, and it introduces a party who is paid whether or not you are right. The upside is a slice. The downside is the position, and sometimes the account, and occasionally the years after that. That asymmetry is not a market opinion. It is the structure of the arrangement.
Then there is the part that makes the sentence permanent: benefit for the rest of your life. A forced exit is not a loss you can average out, because it ends your ability to be right later. Everything in his method depends on being able to wait, and waiting requires that nobody can make you act. Leverage hands that decision to somebody else, on a schedule you do not control and often cannot see.
Which is why the reader's two goals point in opposite directions, and this is the crux. Covering living costs from dividends is a plan that needs the business to keep producing for a long time. Leverage is for people who need the money to arrive sooner than the business produces it. Put those two in the same account and the second one gets to decide whether the first one ever happens. Two goals in one account is not a compromise. It is a competition, and the shorter deadline always wins it. That is not a moral point. It is a statement about which clock the money is running on.
It is also worth noticing that he does not moralise, and that restraint is deliberate. He could have said borrowing to hold shares is irresponsible. He says it is a basic requirement not to, which is a flatter and more useful claim: a requirement is something you check, not something you feel bad about. Rules you can check survive bad weeks. Feelings do not, and bad weeks are when they are needed. A requirement also has the advantage of being answerable in a single word, which a feeling never is.
And the timing of the question matters, because it arrived at the end of a plan rather than the beginning of one. Leverage added later always feels small, since it was added to something that was already working. That is precisely the state in which the risk is largest and least visible: nothing has gone wrong yet, so the constraint looks like a technicality rather than the thing holding the plan up.
A question back
So the question to ask is not how much leverage is acceptable. It is: what would force me out, and who decides. If the answer is a date somebody else set, then the patience in the rest of the plan is rented, and the rent is collected at the worst possible time. A plan that needs ten years cannot be funded by an arrangement that can end in a month. Money that has to be available soon is a different object from money that is available now, and only one of them is worth planning around.