Text
The question
This is Ten Year Lens — twenty years of Duan Yongping's public answers, translated, plus our reading of it. He is one of Asia's most successful investors.
A reader asked whether this was a good business model, and added his own verdict: it does not look like the kind of model you can see at a glance, the way you can with a search engine or a phone maker.
Quote
If you do not understand the business model, then what is it that you like?
The one sentence above is a direct quotation. Everything else on this page is our own summary and reading of it.
Our reading
A reader wrote a careful note. He had liked a Chinese e-commerce company for a long time, but the business model bothered him: the industry is crowded, the products are hard to tell apart, price wars never end, and the company aims at the cheaper end of the market where margins are thin.
The question was a request for a verdict, and the reply declines to give one. That refusal is the content. He is not saying the company is good or bad; he is saying the verdict has no owner yet. There is no person standing behind it, only a set of impressions that arrived from somewhere and settled in. If what you wanted was a verdict, the reply is useless. If what you wanted was a mechanism, it has just told you where to go and look.
Look at what the reader actually wrote, because it is better than he thinks. Competition, sameness, price wars, thin margins, a cheaper end of the market: those are real observations, and several of them are the right things to look at. He is not ignorant. But observations are raw material. A model is what you build out of them, and the building is the part that has not happened.
A model, in this sense, is a short account of how the money gets made and why it keeps getting made. Who pays, and for what. Why they do not go somewhere else. What would have to break for the flow to stop. You can say that in a few sentences or you do not have it. Length is not the issue; a page of adjectives is not longer than four sentences of mechanism, it is just emptier. Mechanism is a plain word for a plain thing: the reason the money arrives, said in a way that could turn out to be wrong.
The word like is the tell, and it is worth being precise about it. Liking is a feeling about a story. Understanding is a claim about mechanics. When the two get merged, the feeling survives every piece of bad news, because it was never tied to any fact that could contradict it. That is not conviction. That is a position with nothing underneath it, and it will not survive a fall in price. A feeling cannot be wrong, which is exactly the property that makes it impossible to rely on.
The comparison in the note is also a trap, and a common one. Saying this model is not as good as a search engine or a phone maker is a relative statement, and relative statements are comfortable because they let you avoid the absolute one. Is this one good. Sitting next to something excellent tells you nothing about what you are sitting on. It only tells you where it sits, which is a much smaller question than the one the reader thought he was asking.
Then there is the reason he answers a question with a question, which people often read as evasion. It is closer to triage. A verdict handed over by somebody else is exactly the thing that fails when the price falls, because it was never load-bearing in the first place. He could give an opinion. It would be worth what a borrowed opinion is worth: useful until the day it is tested, and useless on that day. Declining to lend his name to somebody else's decision is a strange kind of help, and it is the only kind that leaves the decision where it belongs.
So the useful version of the reader's note would have been a different document. Not what worries me about this industry, but here is how this company makes money, and here is why that still works in ten years. The worries can then be attached to a mechanism instead of floating above it. Most investing arguments are not disagreements about facts. They are two people describing different objects.
A question back
The exercise is five sentences, without adjectives. How this business takes money from people, why they keep coming back, what it costs to serve them, what could stop it, and what you would expect to be true in ten years. Words like great, huge, underestimated and obvious are not allowed, because they are all feelings wearing a suit. If only those come out, you have a like. A like is not a business.